The Chronicles of Narnia and Harry Potter are two of the most popular and influential fantasy series of all time. Both have captivated millions of readers with their imaginative worlds, memorable characters, and epic adventures. But are they related in any way? Do they share a common fictional universe, or are they completely separate creations? In this article, we will explore some of the similarities and differences between Narnia and Harry Potter, and see if there is any evidence to support or refute the idea that they are connected.
Contents
The Genres: Fantasy and Adventure
One of the most obvious similarities between Narnia and Harry Potter is that they both belong to the genres of fantasy and adventure. Fantasy is a genre of fiction that uses magic, supernatural elements, or other imaginative devices to create stories that are not possible in reality. Adventure is a genre of fiction that focuses on exciting and often dangerous actions, journeys, or quests of the protagonists.
Both Narnia and Harry Potter use fantasy elements to create their magical worlds, where anything can happen. They also feature adventure elements, as the main characters face various challenges, enemies, and mysteries in their quests to save their worlds from evil. Both series appeal to children and adults alike, as they offer escapism, wonder, and excitement.
The Characters: Four Children with Distinct Personalities
Another similarity between Narnia and Harry Potter is that they both center on four main characters who are children with distinct personalities. In Narnia, the four Pevensie siblings are Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy. In Harry Potter, the four friends are Harry, Ron, Hermione, and Neville.
According to MuggleNet, the personalities of the four Pevensie children map perfectly onto the four founders of Hogwarts: Lucy is a kind-hearted Hufflepuff, Susan is a practical and intellectual Ravenclaw, Peter is a brave and rash Gryffindor, and Edmund is a complicated and ambitious Slytherin. This could suggest that J.K. Rowling was inspired by Narnia when she created her characters.
However, this does not mean that the characters are exactly the same. Each character has their own unique traits, flaws, strengths, and arcs that make them different from their counterparts. For example, Lucy is more faithful and optimistic than Neville, Susan is more skeptical and worldly than Hermione, Peter is more prideful and impulsive than Harry, and Edmund is more redeemable and loyal than Ron.
The Worlds: Parallel Realities with Different Rules
A major difference between Narnia and Harry Potter is that they have different rules for how their worlds work. In Narnia, the world is a parallel reality that can be accessed through various portals from our world, such as a wardrobe, a painting, or a train station. In Harry Potter, the world is the same as ours, but with a hidden magical society that coexists with the non-magical one.
In Narnia, magic can be learned (and used in a haphazard fashion) by anyone who has access to it. In Harry Potter, magic is an innate ability that only humans with magical ancestry can use. In Narnia, there are many different races of creatures, such as talking animals, fauns, centaurs, dwarves, giants, etc. In Harry Potter, there are fewer races of creatures (mostly derived from mythology), such as goblins, elves, centaurs, dragons etc.
In Narnia, time flows differently than in our world: sometimes faster, sometimes slower. In Harry Potter, time flows at the same rate as in our world, except when it is manipulated by magic (such as time-turners).
The Themes: Good vs Evil and Coming of Age
One of the most important similarities between Narnia and Harry Potter is that they both explore universal themes that resonate with readers of all ages. One of these themes is good vs evil: both series show the struggle between the forces of light and darkness, and how the characters must choose their sides and fight for what they believe in.
Another theme is coming of age: both series show how the characters grow up and mature through their experiences in their magical worlds. They learn valuable lessons about friendship, family, courage, loyalty, faith, love, and sacrifice.
The Conclusion: Inspired but Not Related
To conclude, Narnia and Harry Potter are two separate fictional universes that have some similarities but also many differences. They are not related in any canonical way, but they may have influenced each other in some aspects. Both series are masterpieces of fantasy literature that have inspired generations of readers and will continue to do so for many years to come.
